Graphic Card Roundup
A comparative look at what's out there now

By Robert Maloney
March 29th, 2004

ATi Radeon Showcase
ATi's little red devils

ATi's Radeon 9600XT

           
CLICK ANY IMAGE FOR AN ENLARGED VIEW

The driving force behind the ATi Radeon 9600XT is the RV360 core, basically a ramped up version of the RV350 with a 100MHz boost in clock speed. It is also ATi's first graphics core to be based on a low-k dielectric 0.13 micron manufacturing process.  The effects of this are two-fold, allowing for higher clock speeds yet requiring less power consumption. The reduced power needs of the card are obvious when one notices that the 9600 XT does not require any external power connections, even though the core is running at 500MHz.  The reduced power consumption and capacitance should also lessen the heat produced by the VPU, although ATi has still included an oversized aluminum heatsink with a built-in 40mm fan.  It's custom fit, covering all of the space south of the capacitors and stopping just shy of the RAM.  The heatsink is mounted using two spring-loaded retentions clips, and although it may be hard to see in the photo, it makes a solid connection with the RV360.

ATi's Radeon 9800 Pro

         

ATi's Radeon 9800 Pro cooling system is svelte; the cooling fan is quiet and the card takes only one slot location in your chassis. It's the way a graphics card should be designed and the way OEMs want to build them; neat, clean and easy. The heatsink ATi went with this time around, is actually slightly less bulky than even a retail Radeon 9700 Pro board but it does a nice job of keeping the chip cool under full load.  The memory used on this board actually runs pretty hot under gaming conditions.  Regardless, they are fast and rock solid stable up to even 350MHz DDR and higher.  Finally, the 4 pin Molex power connector on the 9800 Pro is much easier to work with (and more abundant in your system) than the Floppy Drive power connector used on earlier models. Also notice the tiny 2 position Dip Switch on the board, right next to the fan power connector. This is for switching to NTSC or PAL format on the TV output of the card.

Asus' Radeon 9800XT/TVD

         

The first thing that jumped out at us with regard to the Asus Radeon 9800 XT/TVD was the bright orange PCB.  It's definitely unique!  The Asus Radeon 9800 XT/TVD conforms to ATi's reference board design, with the exception of the large, dual-fan, copper heat-pipe cooler. The 256MB of high-speed memory used on the 9800 XT was manufactured by Hynix, and was cooled on both sides by the custom Asus heatsink. The heatsink itself is mounted with spring-loaded screws that keep the plates firmly in place. The coolers used on these cards don't encroach on the adjacent PCI slot and we found them to be virtually inaudible next to our CPU's heatsink/fan combo. This card comes equipped with single DVI and DB15 monitor connectors and ATi's Rage Theater chip, which gives this 9800XT its ViVo capabilities.

Comparisons in image quality