SSDs Have High Failure Rate?

Conventional wisdom says that solid state drives (SSDs) should have lower failure rates than their mechanical counterparts simply because SSDs lack moving parts.  Sadly, it seems that theory and reality have clashed once again:

“A large computer manufacturer is getting around 20 percent to 30 percent of the flash-based notebooks it is shipping sent back because of failure rates and performance that simply isn't meeting customer expectations, the firm stated in a report on Monday. Avian gathered this information on a recent swing through Asia.

Approximately 10 percent to 20 percent of the flash notebooks shipping from the large manufacturer are coming back because of technical failure, (Avi) Cohen (of Avian Securities) said, far higher than the 1 percent to 2 percent of notebooks that come back because of technical failure with hard drives.”


Since this study only concerns products from a single company, it is entirely possible that they're placing orders from a limited number of SSD manufacturers.  As a result this could simply be a 'bad batch' or the result of an immature manufacturing process and/or QA procedures that need to be updated.
Via:  CNet
Tags:  SSD, SD, SSDs, Failure, DS, AV, fail, AI
Comments
AjayD 6 years ago
A very logical assessment Chad, I would have to agree. These failure rates are far to high and disproportionate to those of HDs. In all likelihood the notebook manufacturer decided to increase their profit margins by buying the cheapest SSDs they could find. Even if this were a 'bad batch', that would still mean the manufacturer has done insufficient product testing and has very poor quality control. Hopefully this is remote enough of an occurrence not to tarnish the reputation of SSDs.
ice91785 6 years ago
They are still basically in the infancy of their life -- of course its going to take a while to hone them to a find tuned piece of hardware. Until the formula is just right...there will always be a fail here and there which will taper away with time
Marco C 6 years ago
Everyone also has to keep in mind that flash storage can only be written to a certain amount of times before they fail (usually a few hundred thousand times). So, if an SSD's usuage pattern requires many writes and rewrites, it will be prone to failure.
frg1 6 years ago

  i thought they had special wear reducing algorthiums for this

digitaldd 6 years ago

[quote user="frg1"]

  i thought they had special wear reducing algorthiums for this

[/quote]

yes they're similar to what is used in regular hard drives, although they haven't developed anything like S.M.A.R.T. for SSDs yet. Basically an SSD drive is a certain % larger than its stated size the extra space is for error correction so when an area on the SSD fails they swap in a good block from the extra space just like a regular hard disk. SSDs also have another means to make them last longer. Whenever an SSD is written to the bits are moved to different areas on the disk so that the entire SSD wears evenly and one single area isn't always being written to.

Another factor that willaffect how long an SSD lasts is what type of flash memory is used to create it. Did the vendor use the cheapo MLC flash memory that a lot of usb thumb drives & memory cards use or is made of SLC NAND flash which tends to last 5-10 times longer than the MLC stuff. You would think with the cost of SSDs they would all be made from the SLC NAND flash chips but that isn't true.

 

frg1 6 years ago

 you think if they used chepo memory the prices would be lower than what they are now

ice91785 6 years ago
So just out of curiosity BigWop -- what would you say the average read/write rate of a PC is in the course of a day? And by comparison how long would flash storage last an average user
Marco C 6 years ago
I can't really comment intelligently on that. Not sure at all.
frg1 6 years ago

 i guess they like taking are money

peti1212 6 years ago

I don't think I will be getting a solid state drive for a few years just yet. I don't see the good thing about it if you do not have a notebook, and it also seems like the technology is just too raw at the moment for them. I'll wait a bit till everything gets fixed.

frg1 6 years ago

if i want something fast i will just get a raptor

Anne@Dell 6 years ago

The recently published analyst report estimating a high return rate for Solid State Drive technology (SSD) in Dell products is unfounded and wholly inaccurate.  We've posted our  responce on Dell's external blog, www.direct2dell.com.

Dell sees SSD as the future of mobility storage and offers the technology across a wide variety of laptop models, including business, consumer and mobile workstations. Second Generation SSDs, like Samsung’s SATA II Drive, actually outperform existing notebook drives. Dell is offering this drive (called the Dell Flash Ultra Performance SSD) across our laptop portfolio.

trueg50 6 years ago

 Well, this is simply a normal developmental cycle.

 

 First generation of any product will be slow / higher failure rate, but they will improve, and will be superior.

 

Some company was talking about the limited writes, their solution was to throw several gigs of something sort of like RAM for use as a page file / virtual memory. 

frg1 6 years ago

 like a really big cache

digitaldd 6 years ago

[quote user="Anne@Dell"]

The recently published analyst report estimating a high return rate for Solid State Drive technology (SSD) in Dell products is unfounded and wholly inaccurate.  We've posted our  responce on Dell's external blog, www.direct2dell.com.

Dell sees SSD as the future of mobility storage and offers the technology across a wide variety of laptop models, including business, consumer and mobile workstations. Second Generation SSDs, like Samsung’s SATA II Drive, actually outperform existing notebook drives. Dell is offering this drive (called the Dell Flash Ultra Performance SSD) across our laptop portfolio.

[/quote] 

 

So do you know if dell is selling SSDs with the MLC or SLC flash memory in them? or do i have to buy one to find out? 

frg1 6 years ago

 probably just a hardrive labeled as a ssd

Anonymous 6 years ago

hybrid disk drives aren't that good either

frg1 6 years ago

like isaid before if you want good relible speed get a raptor 

ice91785 6 years ago

raptor will give you speed yes -- but the fact that they are 10000RPM creates a lot more heat/vibration and actually makes them more susceptible to failure than would a lot of 7200RPM drives.....

If you want reliabilty and speed -- you would need a few raptors in a Raid 5 or something of the sort

frg1 6 years ago

i still think a raptor is more realible than a ssd is at the moment 

Anonymous 6 years ago

The SSD however,is completely silent,and the Raptor is louder than a lot of normal performance hard-drives.

frg1 6 years ago

get a silencer it will still be cheaper to get a hdd silencer and the raptor  than a ssd alone 

ice91785 6 years ago

[quote user="frg1"]i still think a raptor is more realible than a ssd is at the moment[/quote]

 

Based on what?

willardcw4 6 years ago

id say based on the price performance point :) you can get a nice WD hard drive for a lot less than a comparable SSD (size wise)... and i've been reading a lot of articles talking about the prematurity of SSDs, they arn't necessarily more efficient and can in some cases, be less efficient... hell, I could setup a Raid 0+1 for less money that an SSD.... 500 GB HDs are cheaapp!

ice91785 6 years ago

well yes that addresses the performance but not the reliability issue.........

I would tend to agree with you on the RAID -- really what is stopping you from RAID 5; you get performance AND reliability this way. SSD still has a ways to go in terms of both but just the fact that we are talking about it alone shows that SSD is obviously a player in the "storage" game :)

frg1 6 years ago

well im basing the raptor observation off friends who have gotting them  they have never had a problem the oldest one out of the group is only over 1.5 years old but if ssd are failing at this rate it would seem to me the raptor as more realible though i have never seen a ssd so you could be enterly right

coolzonestefan 6 years ago

Some people compared the newest Seagate 7200.11 drives with the Raptor and they said it does pretty well regarding the performance compared to the Raptor.So if you put 2 Seagates in Raid,I guess you get a much better performance,more storage space than a single Raptor 

zingwaves 4 years ago

THIS 20% TO 30% FAILURE RATE HAS ALREADY BEEN CONFIRMED A BOGUS CLAIM made by some uninformed "journalist". SSD's are actually very reliable instead.

THIS 20% TO 30% FAILURE RATE HAS ALREADY BEEN CONFIRMED A BOGUS CLAIM made by some uninformed "journalist". SSD's are actually very reliable instead.

Post a Comment
or Register to comment