The Gigabyte Maya II R9500 Pro
vs.
The Sapphire Radeon 9500 Atlantis Pro
Premium Performance, Mainstream Price

By - Tom Laverriere
& Marco Chiappetta
February 3, 2003

   

The Drivers
The Catalyst 3.0s

 
         

     

A look at the driver interface shows that ATI has really spruced up and fleshed out their product with all the latest features and settings.  ATI has switched to a unified driver suite, now known as "Catalyst".  Since then, ATI users all over have noticed much improvement in the driver development, performance and stability.  Also worth noting is that the frequency with which ATI releases their driver versions has also improved.  For this test we have loaded the Catalyst 3.0 XP drivers.  As you can see, the catalyst driver gives the user many options in tweaking, everything from Anisotropic filtering, to V-Sync, Gamma and Anti-Aliasing controls.  A look at the DX and OpenGL panels shows that they are much more logical and friendly to the average user.  All in all, we really like these drivers, as they give users the a lot of opportunity to adjust the card's performance and image quality

Screenshots: In-Game Action
Some Nice Looking Visuals

We took some in game screen shots from the latest in the Need For Speed series: Need For Speed: Hot Pursuit 2 .  This game is gorgeous and offers some great eye candy.  For these particular shots we put all the settings at the highest quality possible.  Each screen shot was taken at a resolution of 1024x768 with 32-bit color, 16X Anisotropic Filtering and 6X FSAA.  When looking closely at these shots we can see that all the edges are crisp and clean and nothing appears jagged.  I must say that I was truly amazed at the textures and lighting even with Anti-Aliasing enabled.  I would like to add that even with these strenuous settings, the game remained perfectly playable with no noticeable lag or choppiness.  We were simply amazed with the quality of both rendering and frame rate performance of the R9500 Pro cards.

A WORD ON 2D IMAGE QUALITY & DVD PLAYBACK:

We did not do any "formal" testing of 2D image quality, but we can say from using both of these cards for quite some time, that their 2D output is top notch.  With our Windows desktop set to 1600x1200 with 75Hz refresh rate, text remained crisp from corner to corner on our 19" Samsung monitor.  Colors also remained very uniform across the entire screen.  It was tough to pick out any differences in a Side-by-side comparisons to a GF4 Ti4600, but the RADEONs did seem to produce slightly more vivid images.  DVD playback using both PowerDVD and WinDVD was phenomenal with both the Sapphire and the Gigabyte.  DVD playback has always been one of ATi's strong suits.

BEFORE WE GET TO THE BENCHMARKS:

Due to the fact that we have seen significant variations in benchmark scores from one site to the next, we feel it is necessary to explain exactly how we configure our test systems before running any benchmarks. When testing these video cards, the first thing we did was enter the system BIOS on our P4X400 DRAGON, loaded "Optimized Defaults" and set a 256MB AGP Aperture size.  We then set the "System Performance" option to "Fast" and configured our RAM to run at 166MHz (DDR333).  We set the other memory timings to their most aggressive settings, 2-2-5-2, with a 1T Command rate using 4-Bank Interleaving.  The RAID 0 array, consisting of two Western Digital 80GB "Special Addition" drives, was then formatted, and Windows XP Professional (SP1) was installed. After the installation was complete, we hit the Windows Update site and downloaded all of the available updates including DX9. Then we installed all of the necessary drivers, and disabled then removed Windows Messenger from the system.  Auto-Updating and System Restore were also disabled, and we setup a 768MB permanent page file on the same partition and drive as the Windows installation. Lastly we set Windows XP's Visual Effects to "best performance", installed all of the benchmarking software, defragged the hard drive and ran all of the tests at our CPU's default clock speed.  Throughout our testing, we used ATi's v6.14.01.6255 "Catalyst 3.0" Drivers with the v6.14.10.4012 Control Panels, and VIA's latest v4.45 "Hyperion" 4-In-1 chipset drivers.  For the sake of comparison, we used a Gainward GF4 Ti4600 with NVIDIA's latest "official" Detonators, v41.09.  Now, it's time for our results...

Our Test System & Some Numbers